41.8 Dilations
Definition 41.8.1 (Compression).label Let $H$ be a complex Hilbert space, $K \subset H$ be a closed subspace, $P \in B(H)$ be the orthogonal projection onto $K$, $S \in B(K)$, and $T \in B(H)$, then $S$ is a compression of $T$ if $S = PT|_{K}$.
Definition 41.8.2 (Dilation).label Let $H$ be a complex Hilbert space and $T \in B(H)$, then a dilation of $T$ is a pair $(K, S)$ where:
- (1)
$K$ is a Hilbert space containing $H$.
- (2)
$S \in B(K)$.
- (3)
If $P \in B(K)$ is the orthogonal projection onto $H$, then $T = PS|_{H}$.
If $T^{n} = PS^{n}|_{H}$ for all $n \in \natz$, then $S$ is a power dilation of $T$.
Lemma 41.8.3.label Let $H$ be a complex Hilbert space, $T \in B(H)$, $(K, S)$ be a power dilation of $T$, and $P \in B(K)$ be the orthogonal projection onto $H$, then
- (1)
$(K, S^{*})$ is a power dilation of $T^{*}$.
- (2)
For any $p, q \in \complex[z]$,
\[p(T) + q(T)^{*} = P[p(S) + q(S)^{*}]|_{H}\]
Proof. (1): For any $\xi, \eta \in H$ and $n \in \natp$, $P\xi = \xi$ and $P\eta = \eta$, so
$\square$
Lemma 41.8.4.label Let $H$ be a complex Hilbert space, $R \in B(H)$, $(K, S)$ be a dilation of $R$, and $(L, T)$ be a dilation of $S$, then $(L, T)$ is a dilation of $R$.
Similarly, if $(K, S)$ is a power dilation of $R$ and $(L, T)$ is a power dilation of $S$, then $(L, T)$ is a power dilation of $R$.
Theorem 41.8.5 (Stinespring’s Dilation Theorem).label Let $A$ be a unital $C^{*}$-algebra, $H$ be a complex Hilbert space, and $\phi: A \to B(H)$ be a completely positive map, then there exists a triple $(\pi, V, K)$, where:
- (a)
$K$ is a complex Hilbert space.
- (b)
$V: H \to K$ is a continuous linear map.
- (c)
$\pi: A \to B(K)$ is a unital *-homomorphism.
such that:
- (1)
$\norm{\phi(1_A)}_{B(H)}= \norm{V}_{L(H; K)}^{2}$.
- (2)
For all $a \in A$, $\phi(a) = V^{*}\pi(a)V$.
Moreover, if $\phi$ is unital, then:
- (3)
$V$ is an isometry.
- (4)
Under the identification that $H = V(H) \subset K$, $(K, \pi(a))$ is a dilation of $\phi(a)$ for all $a \in A$.
The triple $(\pi, V, K)$ is a Stinespring representation of $\phi$. If $\bracsn{\pi(a)VH|a \in A}$ is dense in $K$, then $(\pi, V, K)$ is minimal[1].
Proof, [Theorem 4.1, Po02]. (a): Let $A \otimes H$ be the algebraic tensor product and define the Hermitian form
For each $\sum_{j = 1}^{n} a_{j} \otimes \xi_{j} \in A \otimes H$, let $\xi = (\xi_{1}, \cdots, \xi_{n}) \in H^{n}$ and
then since $\phi$ is completely positive,
and $\dpn{\cdot, \cdot}{\phi}$ is a pseudo-inner product.
Let $N = \bracsn{u \in A \otimes H| \dpn{u, u}{\phi} = 0}$. For any $u \in N$ and $v \in A \otimes H$, by the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality,
so $N = \bracsn{u \in A \otimes H|\dpn{u, v}{\phi} = 0 \forall v \in A \otimes H}$.
Let $K_{0} = (A \otimes H)/N$ and $K$ be the completion of $K_{0}$ with respect to $\dpn{\cdot, \cdot}{\phi}$, then $K$ is a complex Hilbert space.
(b): Let $V: H \to K_{0}$ be defined by $\xi \mapsto 1_{A} \otimes \xi + N$, then for each $\xi \in H$,
so $\norm{V}_{L(H; K)}^{2} \le \norm{\phi(1_A)}_{B(H)}$.
(c): For each $a \in A$, let
then for any $u = \sum_{j = 1}^{n} b_{j} \otimes \xi_{j} \in A \otimes H$,
so $\norm{\pi(a)}_{B(K_0)}\le \norm{a}_{A}$. By the Linear Extension Theorem, $\pi(a)$ extends uniquely to an operator in $B(K)$, and $\pi: A \to B(K)$ is a bounded linear map.
By definition, $\pi$ is a unital homomorphism of Banach algebras. Finally, for any $a \in A$ and $b \otimes \xi, c \otimes \eta \in A \otimes H$,
By linearity, $\dpn{\pi(a^*)u, v}{K_0}= \dpn{u, \pi(a)v}{K_0}$ for all $u, v \in K_{0}$. As $K_{0}$ is dense in $K$, $\pi(a^{*}) = \pi(a)^{*}$, so $\pi$ is a unital *-homomorphism.
(1): For each $\xi \in H$,
so
(2): For each $a \in A$ and $\xi, \eta \in H$,
so $V^{*}\pi(a)V = \phi(a)$.
(3): If $\phi$ is unital, then for each $\xi \in H$,
so $V$ is an isometry.
(4): Suppose that $\phi$ is unital, then $V$ is an isometry by (3). Under the identification that $H = V(H) \subset K$, let $P \in B(K)$ be the orthogonal projection onto $H$, then for each $a \in A$ and $\xi, \eta \in H$,
Therefore $\phi(a) = P\pi(a)|_{H}$, and $(K, \pi(a))$ is a dilation of $\phi(a)$.$\square$
Proposition 41.8.6 (Uniqueness of Minimal Stinespring Representations).label Let $A$ be a unital $C^{*}$-algebra, $H$ be a complex Hilbert space, $\phi: A \to B(H)$ be a completely positive map, and $(\pi_{1}, V_{1}, K_{1}), (\pi_{2}, V_{2}, K_{2})$ be minimal Stinespring representations for $\phi$, then there exists a unitary equivalence $U: K_{1} \to K_{2}$ such that $UV_{1} = V_{2}$.
Proof, [Proposition 4.2, Po02]. Suppose there exists a unitary equivalence $U: K_{1} \to K_{2}$ such that $UV_{1} = V_{2}$, then for each $\seqf{a_j}\subset A$ and $\seqf{\xi_j}\subset H$,
By minimality, $\pi_{1}(A)V_{1}H$ is dense in $K_{1}$, and $\pi_{2}(A)V_{2}H$ is dense in $K_{2}$. As such, it is sufficient to show that the mapping $\sum_{j = 1}^{n} \pi_{1}(a_{j})V_{1}\xi_{j} \mapsto \sum_{j = 1}^{n} \pi_{2}(a_{j})V_{2}\xi_{j}$ is a well-defined isometry. To this end, note that
$\square$
Theorem 41.8.7 (Sz.-Nagy’s Dilation Theorem).label Let $H$ be a complex Hilbert space and $T \in B(H)$ with $\norm{T}_{B(H)}\le 1$, then there exists a unitary power dilation $(K, U)$ of $T$ such that:
- (1)
$K$ is the smallest closed reducing subspace for $U$ containing $H$ such that $T^{n} = P_{H}U^{n}|_{H}$[2] for all $n \in \natz$.
- (U)
For any unitary power dilation $(K', U')$ satisfying (1), there exists a unitary $V: K \to K'$ such that $V|_{H}= I_{H}$ and $VUV^{*} = U'$.
Constructive proof without uniqueness, [Theorem 1.1, Po02]. Using Lemma 41.8.4, it is sufficient to show the following statements:
- (i)
For any $T \in B(H)$ with $\norm{T}_{B(H)}\le 1$, there exists an isometric power dilation of $T$.
- (ii)
For any isometry $V \in B(H)$, there exists a unitary power dilation of $V$.
(i): Since $\norm{T}_{B(H)}\le 1$, $1 - T^{*}T \ge 0$, and $(1 - T^{*}T)^{1/2}$ is well-defined. Let $D_{T} = (1 - T^{*}T)^{1/2}$, and
then for each $x \in H$,
Thus for each $x = \seq{x_n}\in l^{2}(H)$,
So $V$ is an isometry. Moreover, $[V^{n}(x, 0, \cdots)]_{1} = T^{n}x$ for all $n \in \natz$. Therefore under the identification that $H = \bracsn{(x, 0, \cdots)|x \in H}\subset l^{2}(\natp; H)$, $V$ is an isometric power dilation of $T$.
(ii): Let $P = I_{H} - VV^{*}$ be the projection onto $V(H)^{\perp}$, and $U \in B(H^{2})$ be defined by
then
so $U$ is unitary. Moreover, for each $n \in \natp$,
Under the identification that $H = \bracsn{(x, 0)|x \in H}\subset H^{2}$, let $Q \in B(H^{2})$ be the projection onto the first summand, then $QU^{n}|_{H}= V^{n}$ for all $n \in \natp$. Therefore $U$ is a unitary power dilation of $V$.$\square$
Proof, using Stinespring’s Dilation Theorem, [Theorem 4.3, Po02]. (1): Let $\mathbb{T}= \partial B_{\complex}(0, 1)$. By Theorem 41.7.3, the mapping
extends to a unital positive map $C(\mathbb{T}; \complex) \to B(H)$, which is completely positive by Stinespring’s Theorem.
Let $(\pi, V, K)$ be a minimal Stinespring representation for $\phi$ and $U := \pi(z) \in U(B(K))$, then for each $n \in \natz$,
so $(K, U)$ is a unitary power dilation of $T$.
(U): By the Stone-Weierstrass Theorem, $(\pi, V, K)$ is minimal if and only if the span of $\bigcup_{n \in \integer}U^{n} H$ is dense in $K$, if and only if $U$ admits no non-trivial reducing subspace.
By uniqueness of minimal Stinespring representations, such a dilation is unique.$\square$
Theorem 41.8.8 (Von Neumann’s Inequality).label Let $H$ be a complex Hilbert space and $T \in B(H)$ with $\norm{T}_{B(H)}\le 1$, then for any $p, q \in \complex[x]$,
Proof, [Corollary 1.2, Po02]. By Sz.-Nagy’s Dilation Theorem, $T$ admits a unitary power dilation $(K, U)$. Let $P \in B(K)$ be the orthogonal projection onto $H$, then by Lemma 41.8.4,
As $U$ is unitary, the continuous functional calculus shows that $\norm{p(U) + q(U)^*}_{B(K)}\le \sup_{z \in B_\complex(0, 1)}|p(z) + \ol{q(z)}|$. Therefore
$\square$
Proof, [Exercise 2.15, Po02]. Assume without loss of generality that $\norm{T}_{B(H)}< 1$. Let
Let $p, q \in \complex[z]$ and $\gamma: [0, 2\pi] \to \complex$ be defined by $\gamma(t) = e^{it}$, then by the holomorphic functional calculus,
For each $n \in \natz$, since $\gamma([0, 2\pi]) \subset \partial B_{\complex}(0, 1)$, $\ol{\lambda^n}= \lambda^{-n}$. After passing through a Neumann series,
By linearity and Cauchy’s integral formula,
so
Similarly,
Therefore
Now, for each $t \in [0, 2\pi]$,
so by the resolvent identity,
Let $M = \sup_{z \in \partial B_\complex(0, 1)}|p(z) + \ol{q(z)}|$. For each $\xi, \eta \in H$, let $\dpn{\xi, \eta}{t}= \dpn{P(T; t)\xi, \eta}{H}$, then $\dpn{\cdot, \cdot}{t}$ is a pseudo inner product on $H$. Hence by the Cauchy-Schwarz inequality,
Since $I_{H} = \frac{1}{2\pi}\int_{0}^{2\pi}P(T; t)dt$,
Therefore $\dpn{[p(T) + q(T)^*]\xi, \eta}{H}\le M\norm{\xi}_{H}\norm{\eta}_{H}$, and $\norm{[p(T) + q(T)^*]}_{B(H)}\le M$.$\square$
Theorem 41.8.9 (Von Neumann’s Inequality for Matrices).label Let $n \in \natp$, $T \in M_{n}(\complex)$ with $\norm{T}_{M_n(\complex)}\le 1$, and $U, V, S \in M_{n}(\complex)$ such that:
- (a)
$U, V$ are unitary.
- (b)
$S = \text{diag}(s_{1}, \cdots, s_{n})$, where $\seqf{s_j}\subset [0, 1]$.
- (c)
$T = USV$.
Let $B = \ol{B_\complex(0, 1)}^{n} \subset \complex^{n}$ and
and $p \in \complex[z]$, then:
- (1)
For each $\xi, \eta \in \complex^{n}$, let
\[f_{\xi, \eta}: B \to \complex \quad (z_{1}, \cdots, z_{n}) \mapsto \dpn{p(T(z_1, \cdots, z_n))\xi, \eta}{\complex^n}\]then $f_{\xi, \eta}$ achieves its maximum modulus at a point $(z_{1}, \cdots, z_{n}) \in \complex^{n}$ such that $|z_{j}| = 1$ for all $1 \le j \le n$.
- (2)
For any $(z_{1}, \cdots, z_{n}) \in \complex^{n}$, if
\[\normn{p(T(z_1, \cdots, z_n))}_{M_n(\complex)}= \max_{w \in \overline{B}}\normn{p(T(w_1, \cdots, w_n))}_{M_n(\complex)}\]then $T(z_{1}, \cdots, z_{n})$ is unitary.
- (3)
$\norm{p(T)}_{M_n(\complex)}\le \max_{W \in U(M_n(\complex))}\norm{p(W)}_{M_n(\complex)}$.
- (4)
$\norm{p(T)}_{M_n(\complex)}\le \norm{p}_{H^\infty(D)}$.
Proof, [Exercise 2.16, Po02], attributed to Wermer. (1): By the Maximum Modulus Principle.
(2): Let $(z_{1}, \cdots, z_{n}) \in \complex^{n}$ such that $\normn{p(T(z_1, \cdots, z_n))}_{M_n(\complex)}$ is maximal. By compactness of the unit sphere in $\complex^{n}$, there exists $\xi, \eta \in \partial B_{\complex^n}(0, 1)$ such that
By maximality, $f_{\xi, \eta}$ achieves its maximum modulus at $(z_{1}, \cdots, z_{n})$, so (1) implies that $|z_{j}| = 1$ for all $1 \le j \le n$ and $\text{diag}(z_{1}, \cdots, z_{n})$ is unitary. Therefore $T(z_{1}, \cdots, z_{n}) = U\text{diag}(z_{1}, \cdots, z_{n})V$ is also unitary.
(3): Since $(s_{1}, \cdots, s_{n}) \in B$, (2) implies that
(4): For any $W \in U(M_{n}(\complex))$, the continuous functional calculus implies that
As the above holds for all unitary matrices,
by (3).$\square$
- $K$ can always be trimmed so that $(\pi, V, K)$ is minimal.keyboard_return
- Where $P_{H}$ is the orthogonal projection onto $H$.keyboard_return
Post a Comment