48.4 The Universal Flow

Definition 48.4.1 (Greatest Ambit).label Let $G$ be a discrete group, and

\[\beta L: G \to \text{Aut}(\beta G) \quad \beta L_{g}(\fU) = g\fU\]

then

  1. (1)

    $(\beta L: G \curvearrowright \beta G, 1_{G})$ is an ambit.

  2. (U)

    For any ambit $(G \curvearrowright X, x_{0})$, there exists a unique morphism of pointed $G$-flows $\pi: (\beta G, 1_{G}) \to (X, x_{0})$. Moreover, $\pi$ is surjective.

Any ambit $(Y, y_{0})$ satisfying (U) is the greatest $G$-ambit.

Proof. (1): Let

\[L: G \to \text{Perm}(G) \quad L_{g}(h) = gh\]

be the left translation action on itself. For each $g \in G$, the functoriality of the Stone-Čech compactification implies that $L_{g}$ extends into a continuous map $\beta L_{g}: \beta G \to \beta G$. By uniqueness of continuous extensions, $\beta L_{g}(\fU) = g\fU$ for all $\fU \in \beta G$. In particular, $\text{Id}_{\beta G}= \beta L_{e}$.

Moreover, for any $g, h \in G$, $\beta L_{gh}= \beta L_{g}\circ \beta L_{h}$, so $g \mapsto L_{g}$ is a homomorphism. Finally, for any $g \in G$,

\[\beta L_{g^{-1}}\circ \beta L_{g}= \beta L_{1_G}= \beta L_{g}\circ \beta L_{g^{-1}}\]

and $\beta L_{g} \in \text{Aut}(\beta G)$.

Since $\bracsn{L_g1_G|g \in G}= G$ is dense in $\beta G$, $(G \curvearrowright \beta G, 1_{G})$ is an ambit.

(2): For each $g \in G$, let $\pi_{0}(g) = gx_{0}$, then $\pi_{0} \in C(G; X)$, $\pi_{0}(1_{G}) = x_{0}$, and the following diagram commutes

\[\xymatrix{ G \ar@{->}[r]^{\pi_0} \ar@{->}[d]_{g} & X \ar@{->}[d]^{g} \\ G \ar@{->}[r]_{\pi_0} & X }\]

for all $g \in G$. By universal property of $\beta G$, $\pi_{0}$ admits a unique continuous extension $\pi \in C(\beta G; X)$. By uniqueness of continuous extensions, the following diagram commutes

\[\xymatrix{ \beta G \ar@{->}[r]^{\pi} \ar@{->}[d]_{g} & X \ar@{->}[d]^{g} \\ \beta G \ar@{->}[r]_{\pi} & X }\]

for all $g \in G$. Finally, since $\beta G$ is compact and $X$ is Hausdorff, $\pi(\beta G)$ is also compact and hence closed. As $(X, x_{0})$ is an ambit and $\pi(\beta G) \supset Gx_{0}$, $\pi(\beta G) \supset \ol{Gx_0}= X$.$\square$

Definition 48.4.2.label Let $G$ be a discrete group. For each $\fU, \fV \in \beta G$, let $\fU \cdot \fV = \lim_{g \to \fU}g\fV$, then

  1. (1)

    For each $A \subset G$, $A \in \fU \cdot \fV$ if and only if $\bracsn{g \in G|g^{-1}A \in \fV}\in \fU$.

  2. (2)

    $\beta G$ equipped with the composition law $(\fU, \fV) \mapsto \fU \cdot \fV$ is a semigroup with identity $1_{G}$.

  3. (3)

    (Right Topological) For each $\fV \in \beta G$, the mapping $\beta G \to \beta G$ defined by $\fU \mapsto \fU \cdot \fV$ is continuous.

Proof. (3): By (U2) of the Stone-Čech compactification.$\square$

Definition 48.4.3 (Induced Action).label Let $G$ be a group, $(X, x_{0})$ be a pointed $G$-flow, and $p_{x}: G \to X$ be the orbit map, then the mapping

\[\pi: \beta G \to C(X; X) \quad \pi_{\fU} x = \fU x = \lim_{g \to \fU}gx\]

is a semigroup action of $\beta G$ on $X$, known as the induced action of $\beta G$ on $X$.

Proposition 48.4.4.label Let $G \curvearrowright X$ be a $G$-flow and $x \in X$. For each $y \in X$ and $\fU \in \beta G$, then $y = \fU x$ if and only if $N(x, U) \in \fU$.

Proof. By definition of filter limits, $y = \fU x$ if and only if $p_{x}^{-1}(U) \in \fU$ for all $U \in \cn_{X}(y)$. Since $p_{x}^{-1}(U) = N(x, U)$, $y = \fU x$ if and only if $N(x, U) \in \fU$.$\square$

Proposition 48.4.5.label Let $G \curvearrowright X$ be a $G$-flow and $x \in X$, then the following are equivalent:

  1. (1)

    For each $U \in \cn_{X}(x)$, $N(x, U)$ is infinite.

  2. (2)

    There exists $\fU \in \beta G \setminus G$ such that $\fU x = x$.

Definition 48.4.6 (Left Ideal).label Let $G$ be a semigroup and $\emptyset \ne I \subset G$, then $I$ is a left ideal if for any $g \in G$ and $h \in I$, $gh \in I$. The left ideal $I$ is minimal if there exists no left ideal $J \subsetneq I$.

Proposition 48.4.7.label Let $G$ be a group and $\emptyset \ne I \subset \beta G$. If $I$ is closed, then the following are equivalent:

  1. (1)

    $L$ is a $G$-subflow of $\beta G$.

  2. (2)

    $L$ is a closed left ideal of $\beta G$.

Moreover, for arbitrary $\emptyset \ne I \subset \beta G$, the following are equivalent

  1. (M1)

    $L$ is a minimal $G$-subflow of $\beta G$.

  2. (M2)

    $L$ is a minimal left ideal of $\beta G$.

In particular, minimal left ideals of $\beta G$ are closed.

Corollary 48.4.8.label Let $G$ be a group, then $\beta G$ admits a minimal ideal.

Proof. By Theorem 48.2.4 and Proposition 48.4.7.$\square$

Definition 48.4.9 (Universal Minimal Flow).label Let $G$ be a group, then there exists a flow $L$ such that:

  1. (1)

    $G \curvearrowright L$ is a minimal $G$-flow.

  2. (U)

    For any minimal $G$-flow $X$, there exists a continuous map $\Phi \in C(M; X)$ such that $\Phi(m_{0}) = x_{0}$ and the following diagram commutes

    \[\xymatrix{ L \ar@{->}[r]^{\Phi} \ar@{->}[d]_{g} & X \ar@{->}[d]^{g} \\ L \ar@{->}[r]_{\Phi} & X }\]

    for all $g \in G$.

The flow $(M, \alpha)$ is the universal minimal $G$-flow.

Proof. (1): Using Corollary 48.4.8, let $L \subset \beta G$ be a minimal left ideal, then $G \curvearrowright L$ is a minimal $G$-flow.

(U): Let $G \curvearrowright X$ be a minimal $G$-flow, $x_{0} \in X$, and $m_{0} \in M$. By (U) of the universal flow, there exists a unique continuous map $\phi \in C(\beta G; X)$ such that $\phi(1_{G}) = x_{0}$ and the following diagram commutes

\[\xymatrix{ \beta G \ar@{->}[r]^{\Phi} \ar@{->}[d]_{g} & X \ar@{->}[d]^{g} \\ \beta G \ar@{->}[r]_{\Phi} & X }\]

for all $g \in G$.

Let $\Phi = \phi|_{L}\in C(L; X)$, then as $L$ is $G$-invariant, $\Phi(L) \supset G\phi(x_{0})$. By Proposition 5.16.3, $\Phi(L) = \ol{G\phi(x_0)}= X$.$\square$

Definition 48.4.10 (Minimal Idempotent).label Let $S$ be a compact Hausdorff right topological semigroup and $e \in S$ be an idempotent, then $e$ is minimal if there exists a minimal left ideal $I \subset G$ such that $e \in I$.

Theorem 48.4.11 (Ellis).label Let $S$ be a non-empty compact Hausdorff right topological semigroup and $I \subset S$ be a closed left ideal, then there exists a minimal left ideal $I \subset S$ and a minimal idempotent $e \in I$.

Proof. By Zorn’s Lemma, $I$ admits a minimal non-empty closed right topological subsemigroup $K \subset S$. For each $a \in K$, $Ka$ is closed by continuity of right multiplication and Proposition 5.16.3. By minimality of $K$, $K = Ka$, so there exists $e \in K$ such that $a = ea$. Let $E = \bracsn{b \in K|ba = a}$, then $E$ is also a closed and right topological subsemigroup. By minimality of $K$, $E = K$, and in particular $a \in E$.$\square$

Corollary 48.4.12.label Let $G$ be an infinite group, then $\beta G$ admits a minimal idempotent in $\beta G \setminus G$.

Proof. Let $L \subset (\beta G \setminus G)$ be a minimal left ideal, then $L$ is a non-empty compact Hausdorff right topological semigroup. By Ellis’ Theorem, there exists $e \in L$ with $e^{2} = e$.$\square$

Proposition 48.4.13.label Let $G$ be an infinite group, $G \curvearrowright X$ be a minimal $G$-flow, then there exists a minimal idempotent $\fU \in \beta G \setminus G$ such that $\fU x = x$.

Proof. Let $L \subset \beta G$ be a minimal left ideal, then the mapping $\fU \mapsto \fU x$ is a continuous surjection. As $x \in X = \bracsn{\fU x|x \in L}$, there exists $\fU \in L$ with $\fU x = x$. Let $F = \bracsn{\fU \in L|\fU x = x}$, then $F$ is a non-empty closed right topological subsemigroup of $L$. By Ellis’ Theorem, $F$ contains an idempotent.$\square$

Theorem 48.4.14 (Infinite Ramsey Theorem for Pairs).label Let

\[[\natp]^{2} = \bracsn{\bracsn{m, n} \in \nat^2|m, n \in \natp, m \ne n}\]

be the set of unordered pairs of distinct elements of $\natp$ and $c: [\natp]^{2} \to \bracsn{1, \cdots, r}$, then there exists $A \subset \natp$ infinite such that for any $m, n, m', n' \in A$, $c(\bracsn{m, n}) = c(\bracsn{m', n'})$.

Proof. Let $\fU \subset 2^{\natp}$ be a free ultrafilter. For each $n \in \natp$ and $1 \le i \le r$, let $A(n, i) = \bracsn{m > n| c(\bracsn{m,n}) = i}$, then $\natp = \bracsn{1, \cdots, n}\bigsqcup_{i = 1}^{r} A(n, i)$. As $\fU$ is a free ultrafilter, there exists a unique $1 \le i(n) \le r$ such that $A(n, i(n)) \in \fU$.

For each $1 \le i \le r$, let $B_{i} = \bracsn{n \in \natp|i(n) = i}$, then $\natp = \bigsqcup_{i = 1}^{r} B_{i}$. As $\fU$ is an ultrafilter, there exists a unique $1 \le i \le r$ with $B_{i} \in \fU$.

Let $n_{1} \in B_{i}$, so $i(n_{1}) = i$. Assume inductively that $\bracsn{n_j}_{1}^{N} \subset \natp$ has been defined such that:

  1. (i)

    For each $1 \le j \le N - 1$, $n_{j} < n_{j+1}$.

  2. (ii)

    For each $1 \le j \le N$, $i(n_{j}) = i$.

  3. (iii)

    For each $1 \le j < k \le N$, $c(\bracsn{n_j, n_k}) = i$.

Let $n_{N+1}\in B_{i} \cap \bigcap_{j = 1}^{N} A(n_{j}, i)$, then:

  1. (1)

    As $n_{N+1}\in A(n_{N}, i)$, $n_{N+1}> n_{N}$.

  2. (2)

    Since $n_{N+1}\in B_{i}$, $i(n_{N+1}) = i$.

  3. (3)

    For each $1 \le j \le N$, $n_{N+1}\in A(n_{j}, i) = A(n_{j}, i(n))$, so $c(\bracsn{n_j, n_{N+1}}) = i$.

By induction, there exists $\seq{n_j}\subset \natp$ such that $c(\bracsn{n_j, n_k}) = i$ for all $j, k \in \natp$ with $j \ne k$.$\square$

Lemma 48.4.15 (Idempotent Refinement).label Let $S$ be a semigroup and $f \in \beta S$ be idempotent, then there exists a minimal idempotent $e \in \beta S$ such that $ef = fe = e$.

Proof. By Proposition 5.16.3, $(\beta S)f$ is a closed left ideal in $S$. By Ellis’ Theorem, $(\beta S)f$ contains a minimal left ideal $L$, and a minimal idempotent $r \in L$. As $L \subset (\beta S)f$, there exists $t \in \beta S$ such that $r = tf$.

Let $e = fr \in L$, then $e^{2} = frfr = fr^{2} = fr = e$. Moreover,

\[ef = frf = ftf^{2} = ftf = fr = e = fr = ffr = fe\]

$\square$

Post a Comment

Name:Email:
Please enter the tag of the current page (1KA) to post the comment.
Tag: