Proposition 13.1.14. Let $(E, \le)$ be an ordered vector space. If for any $x, y \in E$ with $x, y \ge 0$, $[0, x] + [0, y] = [0, x + y]$, then:

  1. $E^{b} = E^{+}$.

  2. The order bound dual $E^{b}$ equipped with its canonical ordering is a vector lattice.

  3. $E^{b}$ is order complete.

  4. For any $\phi \in E^{b}$ and $x \in E$ with $x \ge 0$,

    \[|\phi|(x) = \sup\bracs{\phi(y)|y \in E, |y| \le x}\]

Proof. (1): Let $C = \bracs{x \in E|x \ge 0}$, $\Phi^{+} \in E^{b}$, and

\[\Phi^{+}: C \to [0, \infty) \quad x \mapsto \sup(f([0, x]))\]

then for any $x, y \in C$ and $\lambda \in \real$ with $\lambda \ge 0$,

\begin{align*}\Phi^{+}(\lambda x + y)&= \sup(f([0, \lambda x + y])) = \sup(f(\lambda [0,x]) + f([0, y])) \\&= \lambda \sup(f([0, x])) + \sup(f([0, y])) = \lambda \Phi^{+}(x) + \Phi^{+}(y)\end{align*}

Let

\[\Phi: E \to \real \quad x \mapsto \Phi^{+}(x^{+}) - \Phi^{+}(x^{-})\]

then $\Phi$ is a positive linear functional by Lemma 13.1.13.

For any $x \in C$, $\Phi(x) \ge \phi(x)$, so $\Phi \ge \phi$. On the other hand, let $\psi \in \hom(E; \real)$ such that $\psi \ge 0$ and $\psi \ge \phi$, then for each $x \in C$, $\psi(x) \ge \sup(\phi([0, x]))$. Therefore $\Phi = 0 \vee \phi$.

Since $0 \wedge \phi = -(0 \vee -\phi)$, $\phi = (0 \vee \phi) - (0 \vee -\phi)$ is a sum of two positive linear functionals, so $E^{b} = E^{+}$.

(2): For any $x, y \in E^{b}$, $x \wedge y = (x - y) \wedge 0 + y$ and $x \vee y = (x - y) \vee 0 + y$, so $E^{b}$ is a lattice.

(3): Let $A \subset E^{b}$ be order bounded, then since $E^{b}$ is a lattice, assume without loss of generality that $A$ is upward-directed under the canonical ordering. Let

\[\phi: C \to [0, \infty) \quad x \mapsto \sup_{f \in A}f(x)\]

then for any $\lambda \ge 0$ and $x \in C$, $\phi(\lambda x) = \lambda \phi(x)$. Let $x, y \in C$, then for any $f \in A$,

\[f(x + y) = f(x) + f(y) \le \phi(x) + \phi(y)\]

As this holds for all $f \in A$, $\phi(x + y) \le \phi(x) + \phi(y)$. On the other hand, for any $f, g \in A$, there exists $h \in A$ such that

\[h(x + y) = h(x) + h(y) \ge f(x) + g(y)\]

Since such an $h \in A$ exists for all $f, g \in A$, $\phi(x + y) \ge \phi(x) + \phi(y)$.

By Lemma 13.1.13, the mapping

\[\Phi: E \to \real \quad x \mapsto \phi(x^{+}) - \phi(x^{-})\]

is a positive linear functional on $E$. By definition $\Phi \ge f$ for all $f \in A$. If $\psi \in \hom(E; \real)$ is a linear functional such that $\psi \ge f$ for all $f \in A$, then for any $x \in C$, $\psi(x) \ge \sup_{f \in A}f(x)$. Therefore $\Phi = \sup(A)$, and $E^{b}$ is order complete.

(3): Let $\phi \in E^{b}$ and $x \in E$ with $x \ge 0$, then by (1),

\begin{align*}|\phi|(x)&= \sup(\phi([0, x])) + \sup(-\phi([0, x])) \\&= \sup\bracs{\phi(u) - \phi(v)| u, v \in [0, x]}\end{align*}

For any $u, v \in [0, x]$, $|u - v| \le x$, so

\[|\phi|(x) \le \sup\bracs{\phi(y)|y \in E, |y| \le x}\]

On the other hand, for any $y \in E$ with $|y| \le x$, $y^{+}, y^{-} \le x$, so

\[\phi(y) = \phi(y^{+}) - \phi(y^{-}) \le \sup\bracs{\phi(u) - \phi(v)| u, v \in [0, x]}= |\phi|(x)\]

Therefore

\[|\phi|(x) = \sup\bracs{\phi(y)|y \in E, |y| \le x}\]
$\square$