Theorem 37.7.11 (”Cantor-Bernstein”).label Let $H$ be a complex Hilbert space, $A \subset B(H)$ be a von Neumann algebra, and $P, Q \in \text{Proj}(A)$. If $P \preceq Q$ and $Q \preceq P$, then $P \sim Q$.

Proof, [Lemma 25.1, Zhu93]. Let $U, V \in A$ be partial isometries such that $P = U^{*}U$, $UU^{*} \le Q$, $Q = V^{*}V$, and $VV^{*} \le P$. Denote $Q_{0} = Q$ and $P_{0} = P$. For each $n \in \natz$, inductively define $P_{n+1}= VQ_{n}V^{*}$ and $Q_{n+1}= UP_{n}U^{*}$, then:

  1. (i)

    For each $n \in \natz$, $P_{n}, Q_{n} \in \text{Proj}(A)$.

  2. (ii)

    For each $n \in \natz$, $P_{n} \le P$ and $Q_{n} \le Q$.

  3. (iii)

    For each $n \in \natz$, $P_{n+1}\le P_{n}$ and $Q_{n+1}\le Q_{n}$.

As $\seq{P_n}, \seq{Q_n}\subset \text{Proj}(A)$ are non-increasing sequences, by Theorem 37.3.1, there exists $P_{\infty}, Q_{\infty} \in \text{Proj}(A)$ such that $P_{n} \to P_{\infty}$ and $Q_{n} \to Q_{\infty}$ in the strong operator topology as $n \to \infty$.

For each $n \in \natz$, $U(P_{n} - P_{n+1})U^{*} = Q_{n+1}- Q_{n+2}$, so

\begin{align*}[U(P_{n} - P_{n+1})]^{*}[U(P_{n} - P_{n+1})]&= (P_{n} - P_{n+1})P(P_{n} - P_{n+1}) = P_{n} - P_{n+1}\\ [U(P_{n} - P_{n+1})][U(P_{n} - P_{n+1})]^{*}&= U(P_{n} - P_{n+1})^{2}U^{*} = Q_{n+1}- Q_{n+2}\end{align*}

and $P_{n} - P_{n+1}\sim Q_{n+1}- Q_{n+2}$. Similarly, $Q_{n} - Q_{n+1}\sim P_{n+1}- P_{n+2}$. As $P_{n+1}= VQ_{n}V^{*}$ for all $n \in \natz$, $P_{\infty} \sim Q_{\infty}$ after passing through a strong-operator limit.

For each $N \in \natz$, $\sum_{n = 0}^{N} (P_{n} - P_{n+1}) = P - P_{N+1}$, so $P = P_{\infty} + \sum_{n = 0}^{\infty} (P_{n} - P_{n+1})$. Similarly, $Q = Q_{\infty} + \sum_{n = 0}^{\infty} (Q_{n} - Q_{n+1})$. Therefore

\begin{align*}P&= P_{\infty} + \sum_{n = 0}^{\infty} (P_{2n}- P_{2n+1}) + \sum_{n = 0}^{\infty} (P_{2n + 1}- P_{2n+2}) \\&\sim Q_{\infty} + \sum_{n = 0}^{\infty} (Q_{2n + 1}- Q_{2n+2}) + \sum_{n = 0}^{\infty} (Q_{2n}- Q_{2n+1}) = Q\end{align*}

because $\sim$ is preserved through direct sums.$\square$

Post a Comment

Name:Email:
Please enter the tag of the current page (1DM) to post the comment.
Tag: